The Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail that has stood the test of time, thanks to its simplicity and rich flavor profile. But when it comes to choosing bitters, should you buy aromatic or orange bitters for an Old Fashioned? This question can significantly impact the taste and experience of this beloved drink. Let's explore the differences between these bitters and which one might be best for your Old Fashioned.

What are Aromatic Bitters?

Aromatic bitters are made from a blend of herbs, spices, and botanicals. Some of the most well-known brands include ingredients like cloves, cinnamon, and cardamom. These bitters are known for their complex and intense flavors, often adding a depth of spice and herbal notes to cocktails.

In an Old Fashioned, aromatic bitters contribute to the drink's classic taste, offering a rich and slightly spicy undertone that complements the sweetness of the sugar and the strength of the whiskey. They are the traditional choice for this cocktail, and many purists believe that an Old Fashioned isn't complete without them. 

What are Orange Bitters?

Orange bitters, on the other hand, are made primarily from the peels of bitter oranges along with other spices. Brands create orange bitters with a bright, citrusy profile that adds a refreshing twist to cocktails. These bitters bring a zesty and aromatic quality that can enhance the overall flavor of an Old Fashioned.

Using high-quality orange bitters in an Old Fashioned can add a layer of citrus that cuts through the richness of the whiskey and sweetness of the sugar, creating a balanced and invigorating drink. They are an excellent choice for those who prefer a bit of brightness in their cocktail.

Which Bitters Should You Choose?

When deciding whether to use aromatic or orange bitters for an Old Fashioned, consider your personal taste preferences and the flavor profile you want to achieve.

For a traditional Old Fashioned, aromatic bitters are the go-to choice. They provide the classic spicy and herbal notes that define the drink, adding depth and complexity to the whiskey. Aromatic bitters are essential for achieving that timeless flavor profile that Old Fashioned enthusiasts love.

For a refreshing twist, orange bitters offer a unique citrus flavor that can lighten up the drink. These bitters add a bright and zesty note, making the cocktail feel more vibrant and refreshing. If you prefer a hint of citrus to complement the whiskey, orange bitters can be a delightful alternative.

Experimenting with Both

Why not try both and see which you prefer? Start by making two Old Fashioneds—one with aromatic bitters and one with orange bitters. Taste them side by side to appreciate the differences. You might even find that a combination of both bitters creates your perfect Old Fashioned.

At Tipsy Cocktail Supply Co., you can find a variety of aromatic and orange bitters to experiment with. Our selection allows you to explore different brands and flavor profiles to find the perfect match for your cocktails. It’s time to elevate your home bar in unique ways today!